There’s been another landmark case recently that businesses should know about. In the ruling made in May 2025, it was confirmed that non-verbal expressions (in this case, sighing and frustrated exhales) could amount to workplace harassment and discrimination.
What did the case relate to?
Robert Watson was a software engineer at Roke Manor Research (the company which amongst other things created Hawk-Eye, the ball tracking system used at Wimbledon). He started working for the company in August 2020.
Several issues had materialised during his employment including poor timekeeping and a lack of focus. In September 2022, he spoke to his line manager about the possibility that he may be neurodiverse. His ADHD was subsequently diagnosed in November of that year. He started taking medication and had four days off on sick leave.
On his return to work Watson was confronted by DT, the technical lead of one of the projects Watson was involved in, about the extra work he’d had to do partly due to Watson’s absence. (Because of the firm’s involvement in sensitive projects and associated security concerns, staff named in the claim were only referred to by initials.)
DT questioned Watson’s working hours and patterns, and time spent at his project desk. But he also demonstrated his frustration through what were later referred to as “sighing and exaggerated exhales”. Watson met with DT to explain how this was making him feel. DT’s responses suggested he’d intended for Watson to feel that way. DT also used phrases like “putting your ADHD aside for a moment” and “I feel you are becoming a net detriment”.
In February 2023, Watson went off sick with work-related stress and didn’t go back. He was given warnings over his sickness absences. Watson put in a claim for disability discrimination in May 2023 and was dismissed in January 2024.
So what was the outcome of the claim?
In May 2025, the employment tribunal dismissed Watson’s claim for unfair dismissal and several other counts of discrimination against his employer. But they also ruled that the sighs and gestures were unlawful discrimination and harassment linked to Watson’s disability. While they acknowledged the pressure the situation had created on DT, his behaviour had negatively affected Watson’s mental health. The employment judge commented “Reactions from others, verbally or as a gesture, can have a damning effect on self-esteem and anxiety.”
Watson also succeeded in his claim relating to his employer’s failure to make reasonable adjustments. It was ruled that Roke Manor Research should have acted sooner to identify adjustments that would have helped Watson. Had it provided both Watson and DT with the necessary support, it could have alleviated the work pressure on DT and avoided those discriminatory acts ever occurring.
It’s important to grasp the full implications of this case
This ruling confirms that discriminatory acts are not just about overt comments or actions. Discrimination can also be connected to far more subtle non-verbal behaviours – the kind of actions that can easily be overlooked or missed by others. A repeated pattern of those behaviours can build up over time to create a hostile and difficult environment for an individual. This kind of discriminatory conduct could manifest itself in all kinds of ways. Through someone’s tone of voice for example – perhaps sarcastic comments. Or their gestures, like sighing or tutting or rolling of eyes or other forms of body language. If these behaviours are aimed towards someone with a protected characteristic, it raises the risk for the employer even more.
What steps can you take?
Employers should take action to address these potential risks.
Educate your employees about how these more subtle forms of behaviour can have a damaging impact. Explain how non-verbal behaviours can cause harm to people and the elevated risk for individuals with a protected characteristic. For example, highlight how a pattern of these small gestures in response to performance issues linked to a disability can be every bit as damaging as more explicit comments. In the Watson case, DT didn’t understand the impact Watson’s ADHD could have. That lack of understanding had significant consequences as a result. So make sure you are reminding your managers and employees about what is and isn’t acceptable. Support them by building their knowledge about neurodiversity. Talk about the behaviours needed from everyone to ensure effective relationships and a respectful workplace.
The Watson case is also a reminder that if an employee discloses a disability, you should respond immediately. By looking at what reasonable adjustments can be made, and implementing them, it’ll ensure employees feel supported and help avoid any issues escalating. Don’t forget that discrimination claims are uncapped. The cost of not acting could be considerable.
Do you need help managing your HR obligations?
The world of employment law feels like it’s getting increasingly complicated. It can be tough for businesses to keep a handle on everything. And that’s why we exist. Whether you need some HR advice, more in-depth HR consultancy, or ongoing HR support, we can help you. Please do contact us to have a chat about the many ways that we can reduce or remove your HR burden.

