← Back to HR Blog

What should you do if you think an employee has a second job?

You might have seen some news stories recently about employees caught out for having two jobs on the go and dismissed as a result. It may not immediately sound like something that could affect your business. But employees having second jobs is a practice that might be more widespread than you realise. So what should you do to mitigate the risks and ensure it doesn’t negatively affect your business?

How much of an issue are second jobs?

It goes without saying that it’s a serious issue if an employee is doing two full time jobs. In other words, doing a role at the same time they’re being paid for doing a different job.

You might be surprised by how prevalent this is, partly due to the rise of remote working. Early this year a People Management poll of 1,000 UK workers found that almost a quarter of respondents said they were, or had previously been, secretly working in multiple full-time positions. That clearly isn’t an acceptable situation. And it’s one that most employers would deal with through their disciplinary process.

It’s less clear cut though when an employee is doing a different job, either employed elsewhere or on a self-employed basis, but outside of their contracted working hours.

What are the issues?

Working in two jobs certainly isn’t illegal in itself. But there is a duty of trust and confidence that shouldn’t be breached. So what considerations do you need to be mindful of?

  • Reduced performance and productivity

If an employee is splitting their focus between two roles, and managing different priorities for each, it can lead to a decline in their productivity levels and overall performance. There could be wellbeing and health and safety implications; employees who are feeling overworked put themselves at risk of tiredness, mental health issues and burnout. Exhausted employees could be more prone to making mistakes and causing accidents, putting both themselves and others at risk.

  • Rising absenteeism

The knock-on effect from the above point is that it might lead to an increase in sick days too. An employee might be eligible to receive statutory sick pay (currently £118.75 per week) from both jobs. And bear in mind that the eligibility criteria threshold is being reduced significantly from this April with sick pay payable from day one of sickness (and rising to £123.25). At the same time, the lower earnings limit is being removed – making it considerably more likely that an employee being paid by two different employers will receive sick pay from both.

  • Working Time Directive compliance

There’s also a risk that employers could find themselves breaching Working Time Regulations. An employee’s total hours shouldn’t exceed the 48-hour weekly average limit. Both employers have responsibilities to ensure employees are not working more.

  • Confidentiality might be affected

Confidentiality breaches are a particular concern if an employee is working for another company that’s a competitor or is connected in another way like a supplier. An employee might not intend to share information. But there’s a risk, especially if they have access to sensitive information in their other job.

It’s not all negative though…

You need to weigh up the above however with the fact that an employee having a second job could actually have a positive impact. It might ease financial pressures that would otherwise cause distress. A second job might be an outlet for the employee to do work they love. It could be a source of skill development that your own business benefits from.

It’s really important to strike a balance in the way you respond. If employees are managing their time and responsibilities well in their role with you, it’s difficult to argue that they can’t choose what they do outside those working hours. It could be very counterproductive to restrict how much they can earn by forcing a blanket ban on second jobs.

So what steps can you reasonably take?

  • Check your policies and employment contract clauses

Do you currently refer to secondary employment in your contracts and policies? It’s wise to have a clause that clearly says employees must speak to you if they intend to take on a second job. That said, also remember your response must only be about protecting your business’s legitimate interests and fulfilling your duty of care. So assess every case carefully. You shouldn’t refuse permission if there aren’t genuine reasons why a second job would be a concern.

  • Prevent working time breaches

You need to know what hours are being worked in total. So as well as requiring employees to disclose other jobs, ask them to tell you how many additional hours they’re working. Consider asking employees to sign an opt-out agreement if they do have a second job.

  • Communicate openly

Employees shouldn’t feel anxious about raising the issue of second jobs with you. Keep communication channels open and it will be to the benefit of everyone involved. Even if they’ve signed the working time directive opt out, it’s good practice to make employees aware of their role in managing their total working time from a general wellbeing perspective. There are practical issues too. If someone’s doing self-employed work for example, make sure they know their obligations about filing a tax return so they pay the correct amount of tax overall.

Do you need help managing your HR issues?

Managing employee issues and employment matters in-house takes up a lot of time. As a commercially focused HR consultancy, we can provide you with practical, no-nonsense HR advice tailored to suit your business requirements. Please don’t hesitate to contact us to find out more about how we can help you.

 

Share this article

About the author

Need help with an HR matter?

Talk to Jude Read HR Consultancy about practical support for your business.

Get in touch · Explore more HR articles

keyboard_arrow_up